Key takeaways
- Binding arbitration places contractual disagreements before an independent tribunal for a decision known as an arbitral award.
- A valid agreement must bind the relevant parties and cover the claims being made.
- The seat, procedural rules and applicable laws perform different functions. Their interaction affects how the case proceeds.
- Procedural flexibility does not guarantee speed, low costs or complete confidentiality. These depend on the agreed framework and the conduct of the case.
- A sound strategy considers settlement and the prospects of recovering against assets from the outset.
Facing a disagreement over an international contract? Discuss your options with our Geneva team. Inquire.
Understanding arbitration and dispute resolution
Contract dispute arbitration is a form of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) in which the parties submit a contractual disagreement to one or more independent arbitrators. The tribunal hears the case and issues a binding award. In mediation, a neutral facilitator helps the parties reach their own agreement.
The procedure can address disagreements over interpretation, performance, payment obligations, termination or validity. It is relevant to supply, distribution, services and licensing agreements, among others. An allegation of breach is not essential: parties may disagree about what their contract requires before either has failed to perform.
Before starting arbitration during a contract dispute, identify the available procedure and the outcome worth pursuing. An unpaid invoice, a disputed termination and a threatened interruption of supply may call for different priorities, even under the same clause. The immediate question is how the agreed mechanism can protect the business’s position.
What does the arbitration clause in your contract require?
Arbitration clauses in contracts: scope and parties
Start with the arbitration agreement. Does it cover the claims, and are the relevant parties bound? A clause in a supply agreement does not necessarily extend to a related guarantee, another group company or a separate purchase contract. Check the documents together before deciding whom to pursue and where.
From our practice. In an arbitration under the Swiss Chambers’ Arbitration Institution Rules involving Chinese and Tajik parties, the dispute concerned the purchase of 20,000 metric tons of cotton together with two related guarantees, with approximately US$ 11 million at stake. In a separate ICC matter, eleven parties from Costa Rica, Mexico and Spain, five claimants and six respondents, were involved in a US$ 31.4 million construction and engineering dispute. Where guarantees or multiple entities are present, establishing which documents bind which parties precedes any decision on whom to pursue.
Arbitration clauses do not make every subject arbitrable. Confirm both the agreement’s validity and whether the issues can legally be determined by a private tribunal. Article II of the New York Convention provides the framework for courts in contracting states to refer parties to the agreed forum, subject to the conditions it sets out.
Notice requirements and preliminary steps
Read the contract’s dispute resolution clauses alongside its notice provisions and any required negotiation or mediation. The wording and applicable law determine the consequences of omitting those steps. An arbitration provision may require formal notice even where the parties have already exchanged extensive correspondence about the underlying disagreement.
Keep limitation periods separate from procedural timetables. A demand letter or settlement discussions should not be assumed to preserve a claim. Identify what action is required, by when and against which party. If urgent protection is needed, assess the available interim measures alongside the agreed preliminary steps.
The seat, arbitration rules and applicable laws
The seat is the proceedings’ legal home, not necessarily where a hearing takes place. It determines the national procedural framework and generally the courts responsible for setting aside an award. The law governing the contract determines substantive rights; the arbitration agreement may be governed by a different law affecting its validity and scope.
Institutional procedures govern matters such as appointments and submissions. The clause may for example select the ICC, the LCIA, the Swiss Arbitration Centre or the ICDR, the international division of the American Arbitration Association (AAA). These organisations administer cases; they do not decide the contractual claims themselves.
A Geneva seat does not, by itself, select Swiss contract law or the Swiss Rules. The Swiss Arbitration Centre allows its rules to be used with seats in Switzerland or elsewhere. Confirm the applicable rules and language before planning the case.
From our practice. In an ICC arbitration between two English companies concerning the delivery and construction of industrial goods said to be defective, with US$ 1.1 million in dispute, the tribunal’s jurisdiction and the substantive law applicable to the contract both had to be resolved before the alleged defects could be examined. Two companies from the same jurisdiction, arbitrating under a single clause, still faced a preliminary argument about the framework governing their case.
Arbitration and litigation: benefits and limitations
Litigation places the case before a national court. A lawsuit follows that court’s procedural framework, whereas parties who agree to arbitrate can shape important features of the process, including the seat and selection of decision-makers. That flexibility can be valuable across borders, but it must be assessed against the complexity, value and practical demands of the case.
| Aspect | Potential benefit | Practical limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Neutral forum | Parties can choose a seat outside either party’s home jurisdiction. | The legal framework and available court support still require assessment. |
| Arbitrator selection | Parties can seek suitable legal, technical and language skills. | Appointment rights operate within the agreement and rules; every arbitrator must be independent and impartial. |
| Procedure, time and costs | The procedure can be adapted to the issues and value at stake. | Complex evidence, three arbitrators and extensive submissions can increase time and expense. |
| Privacy and confidentiality | Hearings are generally private; confidential material can receive protection. | Privacy does not create a universal duty of confidentiality. Applicable obligations and exceptions must be checked. |
| Cross-border enforcement | The New York Convention provides a framework for recognition and enforcement. | Local proceedings, refusal grounds and the availability of assets affect recovery. |
Going to court may still be necessary for urgent protection or enforcement. Confidentiality also deserves attention before sensitive documents are exchanged. The ICC Rules permit the tribunal to order confidentiality protections on request; the Swiss Rules contain an express obligation, subject to exceptions. Check what protection the applicable regime actually provides.
How the arbitration process works
Preparing the arbitration case and commencing proceedings
Preparation begins with the commercial objective: payment, continued performance, an orderly exit or a determination of contractual rights. Assess the claim, likely defences and counterclaims against that objective before committing substantial resources.
The initial file will usually include:
- The signed contract, amendments and incorporated terms.
- Relevant correspondence, notices and records of negotiations.
- Performance records, invoices and payment information.
- A chronology identifying the principal events and people involved.
Preserve relevant electronic records promptly. If evidence or assets are at risk, consider whether interim relief is available from the tribunal, an emergency arbitrator or a competent court.
To commence arbitration proceedings, the claimant submits the required request or notice, identifying the agreement, parties, claims and relief sought. The respondent should address the response deadline, any jurisdictional objections and possible counterclaims. Filing requirements and fees depend on the chosen institution and rules.
Selecting an arbitrator and organising the procedure
The agreement and applicable rules determine how the tribunal is constituted, commonly with one or three arbitrators. Relevant experience, independence, availability and language skills all matter. An arbitrator’s role is to decide impartially, including when nominated or appointed by one of the parties.
An early procedural conference establishes how submissions, document production, witnesses and any hearing will be organised. Under the ICC Rules, case management and a procedural timetable form part of that process. The proposed procedure should match the issues requiring a decision. Narrowing the questions early can avoid unnecessary evidence and expenditure.
Documents, witnesses and the arbitration hearing
Written submissions connect the contractual provisions to the facts and the relief requested. Documents establish what was agreed, communicated and performed. Witnesses explain events within their knowledge; experts may assist with technical questions or valuation where those issues justify the expense.
At a hearing, counsel can address the tribunal and witnesses and experts may be questioned. Some cases can be determined on documents alone, depending on the rules and the parties’ rights. The case should remain focused on the evidence needed to resolve the contested issues, with a reasonable opportunity for each side to present its position.
Mediation, settlement and the final decision
Negotiations or mediation can continue as the evidence develops. A party may revise its assessment after receiving the defence, reviewing key records or hearing expert analysis. Counsel should assess these developments against the cost and likely benefit of continuing.
From our practice. In a US$ 12 million matter involving parties from Chad, Bermuda and the United Kingdom, the proceedings concerned a consent award in a construction case. Where the parties reach agreement, recording the terms as an award can give the settlement the same enforceability as a contested decision.
If no settlement is reached, the tribunal determines the claims and any counterclaims in its award. The available remedies depend on the contract, applicable law and tribunal’s powers. The decision may address payment, other contractual relief, interest and costs, as appropriate.
Hypothetical example. A supplier seeks payment while the buyer alleges that delivered equipment failed contractual specifications. The case may turn on acceptance records, correspondence about defects and focused technical evidence. Those materials inform both the tribunal’s decision and the parties’ settlement positions. Whether the supplier could collect an award remains a separate commercial question.
Arbitration awards: challenges, enforcement and recovery
The binding effect of the award and possible challenges
An award binds the parties, but limited avenues of challenge may remain. Their grounds, deadlines and effects depend on the law of the seat. Setting aside proceedings should not be assumed to provide a fresh hearing of the contractual claims.
For international cases seated in Switzerland, challenges generally go directly to the Swiss Federal Supreme Court on restricted grounds, including certain jurisdictional and procedural defects. The Swiss legal framework makes the proper presentation of the case before the tribunal particularly important. Any potential challenge requires prompt assessment and as appropriate must be made promptly.
Recognition, enforcement and recovery across borders
If the losing party does not comply voluntarily, the successful party may need to seek enforcement where assets are located. The New York Convention provides the principal international framework for recognising and enforcing foreign awards, subject to its requirements and limited grounds for refusal.
Enforceability and actual recovery are different questions. Insolvency, competing creditors or assets held by another legal entity can affect the commercial result. Identify likely enforcement jurisdictions early and obtain local advice where needed. A favourable award has practical value only to the extent that it delivers the relief sought.
From our practice. In a EUR 1.9 million dispute governed by French law, concerning fees, interest and costs arising from services provided in connection with a planned low Earth orbit satellite constellation, the respondent was ordered to pay the amounts due to the claimant. An award determines the claim; whether the money arrives depends on the debtor and on where its assets are held.
Commercial arbitration services at Landolt & Koch
Experience across international contracts and legal systems
Landolt & Koch is a Geneva-based boutique advising on international commercial disputes, including those arising from construction and engineering, sales, affreightment, distribution, agency, services and technology licensing agreements. We act as counsel and co-counsel, working with clients’ existing advisers where appropriate.
Our experience across common law and civil law systems helps us address cases in which the governing law, documentary record and tribunal’s legal background come from different traditions. Our work extends to proceedings under different institutional rules and at seats beyond Switzerland.
Our matters range from a US$ 510,000 dispute between Turkish and Tanzanian telecommunications companies over the interpretation of a roaming agreement, to a EUR 21 million claim involving Belgian, Luxembourg and French parties concerning damage to a building and the subsequent warranty, and a US$ 18.5 million arbitration between Turkish and Chinese companies arising from the design, supply and installation of a 600 MW coal-fired power plant. We have acted in proceedings conducted in languages other than English, including a construction arbitration in Italian between two Albanian companies.
Focused advocacy in mother-tongue English
Cross-border cases often bring together documents, witnesses and lawyers working in several languages. The task is to turn that material into a coherent case in the agreed procedural language.
Landolt & Koch places particular emphasis on advocacy in mother-tongue English, supported by multilingual capabilities. We identify the points that matter, develop the supporting evidence and present them clearly in written submissions and at hearings. This also enables us to complement local counsel’s knowledge of the client and its business.
A proportionate strategy aligned with commercial objectives
Our boutique structure supports personal attention and focused staffing. At the outset, we discuss the client’s objectives, the principal risks, the evidence needed and the likely demands of the proceedings. Fee arrangements are discussed transparently, with fixed or capped fees considered where appropriate.
The strategy should remain proportionate as the case develops. That includes revisiting settlement opportunities and planning for recovery. We also assist with enforcement in Switzerland and coordinate with lawyers in other jurisdictions when the debtor’s assets require it.
Discuss your contractual claims with Landolt & Koch to assess the available options and the next steps. Contact our team.
Frequently asked questions
Is contract arbitration possible without a clause?
Yes, if a valid agreement to arbitrate exists elsewhere or the parties conclude one after the disagreement arises. This is often called a submission agreement. One party’s preference is not enough to bind the other. Check related agreements before assuming that the contract’s silence rules this route out.
Is mandatory arbitration enforceable?
A party may ask a competent court to compel arbitration where a valid agreement covers the claim. National law matters: in the United States, section 206 of the Federal Arbitration Act addresses agreements falling under the New York Convention. Relevant state law may also affect formation and validity, subject to federal pre-emption.
What happens if the other party refuses to participate?
Non-participation does not necessarily stop proceedings where a valid agreement to arbitrate applies. The claimant must still establish its case, and proper notice and an opportunity to be heard remain essential. The Swiss Rules, Article 30, expressly provide for proceedings to continue in specified circumstances of default.
Does terminating a contract end its arbitration clause?
Generally, no. The principle of separability treats the arbitration agreement as distinct from the main contract. It can therefore continue to govern disputes about termination or invalidity. The ICC Rules, Article 7, reflect this distinction. The clause’s own validity and scope still require assessment.
What timeline should businesses expect?
There is no reliable duration for every case. Timing depends on the rules, appointment process, complexity, evidence and availability of participants. An expedited procedure may help where available and suitable. Ask for a case-specific timetable, distinguishing the proceedings themselves from any subsequent challenge or enforcement action.
Who pays the costs of the proceedings?
Parties generally fund their own representation and advance procedural costs as required. The tribunal may later allocate costs under the applicable rules and agreement. Recovering every expense is not assured. Institutional estimates, such as the Swiss Arbitration Centre’s calculator, exclude party legal fees and other expenses that affect the total budget.
Can the parties settle after proceedings have started?
Yes. Negotiation or mediation can continue throughout the case. A settlement should address payment or performance, costs and termination of the proceedings. Under the Swiss Rules, Article 36, the parties may request that the tribunal record their settlement as an award on agreed terms, subject to the tribunal’s agreement.
About the author
Phillip Landolt is an arbitration practitioner at Landolt & Koch in Geneva, called to the Bar in Geneva, England & Wales and Ontario. A native English speaker working in French, German and Italian, he acts as counsel and arbitrator in commercial and investment cases, and is recommended by Lexology Index for international arbitration. His publications include EU and US Antitrust Arbitration (Kluwer, co-editor) and leading articles on the scope of arbitration agreements, separability and Kompetenz-Kompetenz. View his full profile and publications on our People page, or contact him directly through the firm.